Christmas in Genoa City is usually a time for crimson poinsettias, warm reunions, and the kind of heartfelt moments that soap fans cherish. But this year on The Young and the Restless, the holidays might be wrapped in danger instead of cheer. A chilling storyline is on the horizon—one that threatens to shatter multiple families, expose long-buried resentments, and push a seemingly rock-solid marriage to the brink.

And according to a recent interview with Brighton James (Devon Winters), the upcoming twist isn’t just dramatic—it’s deeply personal. The actor teased that a looming crisis will hit Devon and Abby in a way neither character has ever experienced before. The stakes? Higher than ever. The fallout? Potentially explosive. And the target of this shocking storyline may be one of the most beloved—and vulnerable—characters in town: little Dominic Newman Winters Abbott Chancellor.

A Calm Before the Storm

For months, Devon and Abby have enjoyed a rare period of peace. They’ve settled into a steady rhythm of co-parenting with fewer battles, fewer outside influences, and far fewer emotional landmines than their past suggested. Devon has been rebuilding fractured relationships. Abby has been rediscovering her sense of stability. Together, they’ve formed what looks like one of Genoa City’s most functional modern families.

But if there’s one thing soap fans know, it’s that calm spells are usually just the ominous quiet before the twist.

Brighton James warned that something “dangerous” is coming—something involving someone very close to Devon’s heart. This crisis, he said, will force Devon to make decisions that may not align with Abby’s loyalties. For the first time, their marriage may be torn between two competing worlds: Devon’s fierce devotion to his family and Abby’s unwavering allegiance to her father, Victor Newman.

Seasoned viewers know: when those two forces clash, the damage can be catastrophic.

A Kidnapping at Christmas? The Terrifying Possibilities

As clues begin to surface, several theories point to a possible holiday kidnapping that could send shockwaves across GC. Who might be abducted—and why? Let’s break down the three most dramatic possibilities currently setting the fandom ablaze.

---

Possibility #1: Baby Dominic – The Story No One Wants… But Everyone Can’t Stop Talking About

Dominic is the heart of Devon and Abby’s family—the miracle child conceived through a complicated surrogacy story involving Mariah, and a baby who carries connections to nearly every major legacy family in the show. That alone makes him a prime target for drama.

Mariah, as viewers remember all too well, struggled deeply after the emotional trauma of carrying the child. Though she sought treatment and stepped away to heal, her long absence leaves room for uncertainty. Has she fully processed everything? Has she healed—or simply hidden her turmoil?

If Mariah returns to town still emotionally fragile, overwhelmed, or influenced by tensions involving Tessa and Daniel, could she make a desperate decision? An impulsive act driven by confusion or unresolved attachment?

It would be a devastating twist. One that would fracture friendships, reignite old wounds, and leave Devon and Abby wrecked.

Losing Dominic—even temporarily—would shatter every character connected to him. And it would certainly launch the Winters, Abbott, Newman, and Rosales circles into immediate war.

---

Possibility #2: Lily Winters – A Family Torn Apart at the Worst Possible Time

Another theory gaining momentum is that the kidnapped victim may not be Dominic at all, but Lily Winters.

Crystal Khalil, who portrays Lily, is expected to step away temporarily for maternity leave—an absence that soap writers traditionally handle with dramatic exits. A kidnapping storyline would not only explain Lily’s disappearance but would pull Devon into a frantic rescue mission.

With Lily’s complicated history with Cane, Billy, and her broader circle of foes and former lovers, the list of potential abductors is long.

But here’s where things get messy: if Lily vanishes, Devon may immediately suspect Victor Newman—especially if any of Victor’s shady business dealings happen to intersect with Lily’s disappearance.

Devon pointing fingers at Victor? That’s a recipe for carnage.

Abby, ever fiercely loyal to her father, would go to war to defend him. And if evidence—true or false—begins to mount, the couple could find themselves fighting on opposite sides of a family battlefield.

Christmas dinner with the Newmans will not be merry this year.

---

Possibility #3: Cane Ashby’s Desperate Move – A Twist No One Would See Coming

Cane Ashby has been off the canvas for a while, but mentions of him and lingering connections keep him in the orbit of several plotlines. And fans know that Cane is no stranger to misguided attempts to “protect” the people he loves—even if his methods backfire spectacularly.

If Cane believes Lily is in danger from someone else, or if he spirals into fear or paranoia, he could conceivably take her himself—thinking he’s saving her.

A self-styled rescue mission gone wrong.

Such a twist would devastate Devon, who has worked tirelessly to keep his family stable. And it would immediately force Abby into a difficult position: support Devon as he hunts for Lily, or acknowledge that Cane may have acted out of fear, not malice?

Either way, the emotional fallout would be massive.

---

A Marriage in Crisis? Devon and Abby Reach Their Breaking Point

Regardless of which theory comes to pass, one thing is undeniable: Devon and Abby are heading into the most intense marital test of their relationship.

Loyalties will be questioned. Ultimatums will be issued. Secrets may surface. And in the middle of it all will be a family in crisis—fighting to keep from falling apart during what should be the happiest time of the year.

Will the holiday kidnapping storyline pull Devon and Abby closer together as they fight side by side?

Or will this be the final fracture—the one they cannot repair?

Soap history suggests that holiday disasters often lead to emotional reunions. But they also often lead to heartbreaks that last well into the new year.

For now, fans can only wait.

---

Who Will Be Taken? Who Will Survive the Fallout?

The tension is building fast, and the clues are pointing toward a holiday season like no other. Someone is disappearing. Someone else is responsible. And the truth, when it’s revealed, will change lives forever.

So tell us, Y&R fans:

Who do you think will be kidnapped—Dominic or Lily?
And will Devon and Abby’s marriage survive what’s coming?

Get ready, Genoa City.
Merry Christmas… or is it?